MOONBI 88
MOONBI is
the name given by the Butchalla Aborigines to the central part
of their homeland, Fraser Island or ìKgariî
MOONBI
is the newsletter of Fraser Island Defenders Organization Limited,
PO Box 70, BALD HILLS, QLD, 4036
FIDO,
ìThe Watchdog of Fraser Island", aims to ensure
the wisest use of Fraser Islandís natural resources.
FIDO's Registered Office:
c/- Stephen Comino and Cominos, Equity House, Lang Parade, Milton,
4065 (ACN 0099-69-135)
ISSN 0311 - 032X
Registered by Australia Post - Publication QBH2293
25 November, 1995
Since MOONBI 87
PLEASE NOTE FIDO's NEW POSTAL ADDRESS:
PO Box 70, BALD HILLS QLD 4036
FIDO is an entirely voluntary organization and the new address
makes it easier for our volunteers such as the very busy Treasurer,
Cr. Terry Hampson, to service membership. Please use the new
PO Box from now on.
Although there have been no new headline making dramas, many of
the issues identified in MOONBI 87 remain unresolved at this stage:
- The numbers of shorebirds on Fraser Island continues
to diminish alarmingly;
- Fraser Island remains a Cinderella World Heritage area;
- Foreshadowed management changes haven't eventuated.
To try to break the impasses we have spent much time
during the last 6 months researching and documenting some of the
on-going issues. In this issue we have decided to do some in-depth
exposes on three main issues:
- Continuing of the Fraser Island Fishing Expo (p2)
- Protecting certain commercial interests (p3)
- Fraser Island numbers may be fee driven (p3)
All of these stories have an unfortunate recurring
theme which points out two major weaknesses in the Department
of Environment and Heritage (DEH):
- It has failed to place the public interest above
certain private interests; and
- It is reluctant to engage in a proper process
of public consultation. There are many examples discovered of
the community being deliberately denied information on deals being
done on behalf of the DEH.
By ignoring these basic principles of public service
the DEH has invited justified criticism.
The Queensland Elections: The surprise results of the
Queensland State Government Election in July are being claimed
as victories by almost every pressure organization from the porn-sex
industry to the Public Land Users Group (a coalition of mainly
rednecks who hate the restrictions of any National Parks). However,
at a time when the Goss Government lost what had been previously
relatively safe seats they held the previously marginal seats
of Hervey Bay and Maryborough. Labor benefitted by having Fraser
Island on the World Heritage List. The National Party candidate
for Hervey Bay lost much support when he suggested having it taken
off the list. Every political party should now learn from this
experience. (Story p. 6)
Curbing the "Cowboys": FIDO wants more urgent
action to halt what they have described as the actions of cowboys
on Fraser Island. Recent inspections have revealed appalling
behaviour by some four wheel drivers who could only be described
as vandals. Signs have been deliberately knocked over by bullbars,
ancient sculptured wood in sandblows chopped up for firewood,
horse trails established along the shores of Lake Boomanjin, and
birds have been run over by vehicles. (Story p. 8)
Sad Fairy Story: Four ferries now carry more than 300,000
visitors too and from Fraser Island each year. However the impact
and the conduct of those ferries is now coming under much closer
scrutiny and it is not just FIDO who are questioning the safety
standards, the service and the charges. (Story p. 5)
Mosaic Makes a Big Picture: Our diary shows that so much
has happened. In the past MOONBI has skipped many of the lesser
issues to focus on the "big picture". However, the
many facets reported in this issue make us question whether everyone
who has a responsibility for management on Fraser Island regards
the public interest or private interests as being paramount when
it comes to decision making.
Still the Cinderella: Since MOONBI 87 there is much more
evidence to support that as the Great Sandy Region has been relegated
down the list of DEH priorities. The Management Plan adopted
last year is now languishing because of inadequate resources and
staff. Signs of neglect are evident all over Fraser Island.
The Eli Creek boardwalk is sinking, planks are falling off the
Central Station boardwalk. Staff haven't implemented road closures
which were to have occurred in April. Unless urgent action is
taken soon some of Fraser Island's greatest icons such as the
rainforest Wanggoolba Creek at Central Station will be so degraded
within 20 years that many of its unique values will be lost.
Many of the long promised changes to Fraser Island management
are still to happen. Fraser Island now vies for the unenviable
title of Australia's most poorly managed World Heritage area.
Wildlife Stories: The demise of the shorebirds on Fraser
Island is now so obvious that everyone recognizes it but decisions
to stop the loss both from incidental vehicle kills and continually
disturbed nesting sites re not forthcoming. (p8)
Contents
How FIDO was Ambushed - The Fishing Expo 2
FOI Suggests new Rules 3
Fishing the Unknown 3
Limiting Fraser Island Numbers 3
Commercial Tour Operations 4
Away in Ferry Land 5
The Political Scene 6
Still Short of Staff - New Fee Structure 6
Failure to Close Roads - Sandy Cape Light 7
Bird Count - Weeds - BBBs Activity 8
Walking Trails 9
Losing Aboriginal Icons, Signs 9
Whats in a Name? Local Authority Boundaries 10
Diary Digest 10-11
199-95 FIDO Annual Report - Join FIDO in February 12
How FIDO Was Ambushed
Conspiring to Continue Fish
Expo
FIDO was not in a position to comment on the 1996
Fishing Expo announced just as MOONBI 87 went to press. We now
have much more information about how we were tricked into dropping
our guard. The DEH does not come out in a good light.
With the close down of the Orchid Beach Resort after it had been
purchased by the Queensland Government for $6 million, FIDO had
anticipated that the ugly Fishing Expo that had developed there
would close down as well. However, the generously cashed up FIRT
Ltd. who had sold the resort managed to persuade the DEH to let
them continue to hold the event there. DEH engaged in no public
consultation reaching that decision. FIDO protested to the Environment
Minister. Molly Robson advised FIDO that there were some on-going
commitments but that 1995 would be the last provided that promoters
abided by an agreement developed in 1994.
FIDO scrutinized the 1994 event and reports we received confirmed
that it was little more than an orgy of drinking for many of the
hangers on attracted to this event. We were reconciled though
with a Ministerial assurance that the event would terminate in
1995. As a result we dropped our guard. We didn't expect to
be sold out by the DEH again. We did not expect to be ambushed
by secretive conspiratorial officers who failed to inform us of
the on-going negotiations with FIRT trading as Kgari Events to
let the event continue in 1996 ó and beyond.
Because the DEH had deliberately kept FIDO and the Community Advisory
Committee in the dark, the first knowledge that FIDO had that
there would be an event in Eurong in 1996 was when the announcement
was made by Molly Robson on 22 May, 1995 immediately prior to
the 1995 Event. The whole process of DEH community consultation
has been a charade.
On 2 May, 95 the DEH officers were uncharacteristically mute at
the 14th CAC meeting about any 96 Fishing Expo. This was only
days before the Minister announced the relocation of the Fishing
Expo. No reports to the CAC meetings had suggested that a 1996
event was even on the cards
DEH's files reveal that:
* Negotiations for the 1996 event began in 1994.
* On 16 December, 1994 Molly Robson advised Leach that "there
is a place for fishing competitions on Fraser Island..."
* Keith Leach advised the DEH in on 8 February that he had agreement
in principle to locate the event at Eurong
Angela Burger of Eurong Resort was the only CAC member
involved in the confidential discussions with senior DEH officers
and event promoter Keith Leach. (Eurong Resort is expected to
be a principal financial beneficiary from the next Fishing Expo).
She was asked not to make any comments at the CAC to alert John
Sinclair before the BIG announcement, a few days later.
On 8 August, a senior DEH officer told John Sinclair that because
FIDO's opposition to the Fishing Expo was well known to the DEH,
they felt no need to discuss the matter of renewing the Fishing
Expo permission when the proponents came to them to discuss changing
the venue from Orchid Beach to Eurong.
When we combed through the files there was only one letter
from FIDO stating our position. Surprisingly there was not one
letter on the file from any angler outraged at the proposed closing
of this event, asking for the event to be continued. There were
plenty of letters from the principal profiteers from the event.
While FIDO is not normally given to conspiracy theories there
is plenty of evidence that a Department which was supposed to
be representing the public interest in this matter had taken the
side of pecuniary interests.
There is increasing community disquiet about many aspects of this
debauched event. Other opponents to the event (besides FIDO)
voiced their anger at the lack of consultation during Community
Advisory Committee discussions. The DEH officers who chose to
speak only to those who would gain some pecuniary benefit from
this event must now wear the consequences.
FIDO Finds Out by FoI
Through a FoI request, FIDO received many documents
relevant to the Fraser Island Fishing Expo. They reveal that
the DEH has been (and continues to be) incredibly slack in exercising
control over this event. It has allowed private interests to
prevail over the public interest.
Some examples we can cite which reinforce this view are:
* The report on the 1994 Fishing Expo event did not
address the issues which were of FIDO's principal concerns. There
was no mention of the competitors' total catch or their impact
on wilderness or wildlife (including fish) other than dingos.
It was a most unsatisfactory evaluation. It is small wonder
that the DEH was not keen for this report to become public.
* There is no report at all on the conduct of the 1995 Fraser
Island Fishing Expo. This demonstrates the DEH's slackness in
monitoring this sordid event .
* Both the 1995 and 1996 Fishing Expos were announced before there
was any evaluation of the preceding event by the DEH. This preempted
evaluation of whether there was satisfactory performance of terms
and conditions of the agreement. These preemptive announcements
helped persuade the DEH to go along with the event organizers.
* Kgari Events now demand two year's notice before the event within
the Fraser Island Recreation Area before the DEH can withdraw
its approval. Because no termination notice has yet been formally
served the event could continue indefinitely due to DEH inertia.
FIDO want Kgari Events notified now that under no
circumstances will permission to conduct the Fraser Island Fishing
Expo be continued beyond 1997 and that no public announcement
about any possible 1997 event can be made until the DEH has concluded
its full evaluation of the 1996 event, the first Fishing Expo
at the Eurong site which should be about 6 to 8 weeks.
FOI Suggests New Rules
FIDO's Freedom of Information search revealed a lot
about the process by which the bureaucracy works. For example,
correspondence addressed to the Minister or the Director General
often doesn't leave the 17th Floor and get passed on to relevant
officers. Similarly many decisions seemed to be made by people
at lower levels without the knowledge or even vague awareness
of their superiors. It is amazing just how many people who should
have been kept informed remained in the dark. In the past one
of FIDO's Golden Rules for campaigners was when in doubt about
who to go to always go to the top. Due to the defects in communication
we have observed in the DEH we can now offer two new rules:
* Copies are cheap. Make several copies of any important
correspondence / submissions and send them to all relevant officers
who should be informed about the matters raised. Given the investment
of time and effort in preparing submissions it is important not
to miss any people who should be aware of the contents.
* Keep good records. When any meetings are held with
any officers of the DEH (or any other Department) keep a careful
note on the meetings, who was at them, how long they lasted and
what was discussed. We discovered that a senior DEH Officer briefing
the Minister on issues to be raised by FIDO in a Ministerial meeting
said, "Many of these issues have been discussed with FIDO
Executive members or with John Sinclair, Honorary Project Officer
on many occasions in the past." However, he did not inform
the Minister of how many occasions and the outcomes of the meetings
were unspecified. FIDO disputes that there were ever "many"
meetings and if they had been resolved then FIDO certainly would
not be raising them with the Minister again. Records are needed
to counter such misleading data.
Fishing the Unknown
The whole matter of the fishery in the Great Sandy
Region remains a mystery because the DEH has not helped inform
all stakeholders about what is known about this vital aspect of
this World Heritage Region. True is that fisheries come within
the Primary Industries portfolio but the CAC have for over a year
urged the DEH to have DPI and fishing industry representatives
attend a meeting to brief all stakeholders on all relevant issues.
We would like to know more about the seasonal closure of the
area around Indian Head and Waddy Point every September. We
are keen to know whether either the area covered or the period
the closure applied is adequate and what has been achieved. We
want to know more about the commercial fishing licenses on Fraser
Island and what rights they give the fishers to access what are
supposed to be vehicle free beaches. Unfortunately the CAC requests
were put in the "too hard" basket by the DEH and so
far the matter has been allowed to languish on the backburner.
The DEH were scheduled to have speakers at the meeting of the
Community Advisory Committee scheduled for 6 November. No attempt
had been made to line up the speakers. Needless to say nobody
could attend at such short notice. This lack of concern for wildlife,
namely fish, and its poor organizing ability does not earn the
DEH many accolades.
Limiting Fraser Island Numbers
There is increasing anxiety in parts of the conservation movement
about how a proposed new road linking the Noosa area direct to
Maryborough would affect the number of visitors to Fraser Island
and Cooloola.
(See 1994-95 Visitor Statistics p 10)
It is FIDO's view that a new road through the plantation to the
west of Cooloola is preferable to the alternative which is upgrading
the Cooloola Way which runs through the Cooloola National Park
and across the Noosa Plain. A new road may also be an opportunity
to cease using the beach from Freshwater to Noosa for through
traffic. It is also FIDO's opinion that it is more important
to develop other ways to place a ceiling on the number of visitors
(which we support). Our considered preferred option is to limit
the numbers who can stay in the parks.
The One way of limiting numbers of Fraser Island and Cooloola
visitors is by limiting the numbers who could stay overnight on
the island. This would require the DEH to establish more designated
camping sites but it would involve the phasing out altogether
of free-range camping except for pedestrian bushwalkers and special
cases. Thus no visitor would be able to stay overnight unless
they had a prior booked camping site or private accommodation
arranged or were hiking away from roads. Such a system already
works extremely well at Lawn Hill National Park. It would require
the DEH to have an integrated campsite booking program in which
applicants for permits would be able to assess their options for
campsites at the same time as they applied for their permits.
While this would inevitably mean the end is free range camping
along the beach, it is a positive move to enable undisturbed nesting
of Oyster-catchers to occur. We are only just discovering the
constant human traffic in the foredune areas has been one of the
factors which has contributed to the dramatic demise of the oyster
catchers along the Fraser Island beaches.
Placing people in designated campgrounds would also eliminate
the looming health problems associated with the lack of proper
toilets and free range camping. It should also eliminate some
of the loutish behavior associated with reckless firewood gathering,
excessive bonfires and noise at night. It would also stop the
alarming degradation of the foredunes.
In short, under FIDO's proposal, while there would be no limit
on day visitations, there would be an effective limit on the numbers
who plan longer stays. In future the numbers of Fraser Island
visitors on any night could be limited by the bed and campground
capacity. Most people agree that the infrastructure for these
camping has significant environmental impact.
It is clear from our FoI search that one reason the DEH has
been persuaded to allow the continuation of the Fishing Expo is
the amount of revenue which the event would generate from access
and camping fees. FIDO had always been apprehensive that fees
may be the tail which wags the dog. The files now have evidence
of that.
Commercial Tour Operations
For reasons which defy logic the DEH is continuing
to enforce a policy which insists that no new commercial Tour
Operators Licenses will be issued to visit Fraser Island. They
are insisting that the only way new commercial operators can gain
access is to "buy" an existing permit. This is having
several effects:
1. It guarantees existing operators freedom from
competition. If a customer is dissatisfied it is unlikely to
affect repeat business since there is very little repeat business
amongst day visitors to Fraser Island anyway. FIDO believes that
the public suffers in the quality of their experience as a result
of this policy.
2. It is making the value of tour permits, which were originally
issued free, now worth up to $250,000. The DEH is facilitating
a market which is not in the public interest and yet it is the
public interest which should be the first consideration of the
Public Service.
3. Escalating costs of acquiring the existing permits (which are
like licenses to print money) are being concentrated into fewer
and fewer hands and is tending towards an oligopoly. In the USA
a similar system was tried and in the end every permit for Yosemite
National Park was held by just one company. When that company
was taken over by the Japanese the American public found themselves
in the invidious position of not being able to visit their
National Park without paying a Japanese company. A similar
situation could easily develop with Fraser Island unless the policy
is changed soon.
4. The power of a few larger commercial tour operators to dictate
the terms of DEH operations on Fraser Island is now very worrying.
The larger operators have virtually dictated the road standards
which will apply and that more priority is given to upgrading
the roads on their routes (often without regard to the environmental
impacts) than to other urgently needed management in other areas.
The whole system is a mockery which effectively preserves
and adds capital gains for the privileged who can afford tour
licenses.
In April, we were advised that a review of the commercial tour
operations of the Great Sandy Region was underway. Nothing further
has been heard of it but we are continuing to make submissions
to the Environment and Heritage Minister to ensure that the best
standards of tour operations possible are being offered on Fraser
Island.
FIDO has developed a very strong case for removing the current
ban on new tour operators entering the Fraser Island tour market
except by buying licenses from existing operators. As
long as a tour operator meets the standards of having appropriate
skills and experience, indemnify the Department with adequate
public liability insurance, pay appropriate fees, complies with
vehicle and safety standards and offers tours which avoid overcrowding
or overuse at sensitive sites such as Central Station, Lake McKenzie
and Eli Creek they should be granted licenses.
Illegal operations: The DEH policy is having the effect
of forcing many aspiring tour operators to operate outside the
law on Fraser Island. During the first 18 days of October several
illegal tour operations were observed. It is inconceivable that
DEH officers were unaware of this. This only reinforces FIDO's
case that the current DEH policy of not issuing any more Commercial
Tour Licenses is farcical and that it should be abandoned.
Ignoring permit conditions: FIDO is curious to learn what
happens if CTO's breach the conditions of their tour permits.
One tour operator was observed moving bollards to get a trailer
inside the camping area at Lake Boomanjin. We don't believe such
action would have been approved. Although these were replaced
it sets an unusual precedent.
Horses for courses: However our greatest criticism relates
to the horse riding tours. The DEH only issued this permit after
the Fitzgerald Inquiry despite FIDO's objections. We believe
that horses have an unacceptable environmental impact including
being a potential source of introducing weeds and disease. Although
this permit is not allowed to be transferred from the present
holder, the DEH seems to be making no attempt to ensure that this
tour operator strictly adheres to the conditions of issue. Anyone
can see the impact on the shores of Lake Boomanjin from the horses
and across the lunette surrounding it as the horse riders create
their own trails away from the established vehicle and walking
tracks. Such new trails are unacceptable and have a serious impact.
Such trails may take many months to recover.
Commercial Joy-flights: There is now a serious problem
of intrusive noise from commercial joy flights on Fraser Island.
None of these are licensed as Commercial Tour Operators and the
numbers have proliferated in recent years. Just a few years ago
it required special arrangements to charter aircraft to fly in
to conduct joy flights. Now there are up to 6 aircraft regularly
parked on Fraser Island's ocean beach and taking off and landing
at all tides to take passengers whom they recruit from people
driving past. There appears to be no control over this proliferation
of joy flights and it is having impacts not only on the beach
and public safety there but it is becoming increasingly intrusive.
Kingfisher Resort Sewage Stinks
Our FoI on the sewage treatment for Kingfisher Resort
reveals some damning evidence of inertia when it comes to the
DEH acting against a self -proclaimed leader in ecotourism in
Australia.
On 3 March, the DEH reported .. monitoring showed non-compliance
.... On 7 March, 95 the DEH were seeking the employment of
a temporary Investigations Officer for the proposed prosecution
of Kingfisher Resort. Suddenly by 10 April (after a year of non-compliance)
the relevant DEH officer (notwithstanding the resort's own monitoring
on 24 February revealing discharge significantly exceeding licensed
standards) recommended against prosecution for many weasel reasons
including "The company would probably not be considered
worthy of prosecution under the Department's Enforcement Guidelines".
Despite a note that "Consultation has taken place with
John Sinclair and the GSCAC regarding monitoring" none
of this information had been communicated especially about dropping
proposed prosecution.
The Good Elves and the Ferries
Sid Melksham now owns and operates three ferry services
to Fraser Island. He runs a ferry from Mary River heads to Wanggoolba
Creek which carries most of the day trippers to Fraser Island.
After having driven out his competitor, Gordon Elmer, on the
Inskip Point run he had the lion's share of the carriage of private
vehicles as well. On 27 July, his refurbished Fraser Dawn began
to operate on the Urangan to Moon Point run. These vessels now
carries more than 300,000 people each way annually. However,
these operations must have been lucky fairies (or elves) indeed
to have so far avoided the scrutiny of the Trade Practices Act
and the Prices Surveillance Authority. The result is an increasingly
dissatisfied public.
Safety for "All Aboard"
In early September, FIDO received a report through
intermediaries from Captain Grieve, an English aviation consultant
who is an international safety expert of long standing. He was
appalled he was by the standard of safety on the vehicular ferry
he travelled on from Inskip Point to Fraser Island. FIDO has
previously been more anxious about the ferry operating from Mary
River Heads to Wanggoolba Creek which is always more crowded and
often has trucks carrying highly flammable fuel and LPG aboard
a barge carrying hundreds of passengers.
FIDO had no alternative but to forward the matter on to the Minister
for Transport. Although Captain Grieve was not contacted and
no Officer of the Transport Department apparently inspected the
ferries, the Minister advised that:
(a) when ferries carry fuel tankers all passengers
be must be accommodated on the other deck.
(b) That ferry operators are obliged to make announcements relating
to emergency procedures are made on voyages of longer than 30
minutes duration and if voyages are of shorter duration there
should be signs displayed on safety procedures on the vessel.
(c) That an "adequate space, a minimum of 750 millimetres
should be left between vehicles allowing passengers to alight"
and there should be a sign displayed on any vehicle which advises
all passengers of this requirement.
During the 6 weeks it the Minister took to reply
a very serious breach of safety was observed on 8 October, when
the last vehicle was loaded on to an already very crowded barge.
After being pushed up against the vehicle in front, its rear
wheels were perched so precariously on the deck that the ramp
could not be raised behind it. So much of the vehicle overhung
the ramp.
This excessive crowding occurred while the other ferry was tied
up on the beach on the other side. The second ferry made no move
to cross the strait to alleviate the overloading which was occurring.
It appears that ferry operators are working to instructions that
they are to minimize the number of ferry crossings by carrying
the maximum number of vehicles which can be crowded on each ferry.
The Minister is pleading for photographic evidence of breaches
of safety but is obviously keen to save the now $50 return fare
for a vehicle so that his Officers could check out what is a matter
of very serious concern. The public interest surely demands that
for this price there should be no short-cuts on safety.
One of the features of better safety standards (if and when
enforced) should be a better ferry service to Fraser Island.
Raising the Fares
The cost of visiting Fraser Island has now been dramatically
raised by the principal opponent to the Queensland Government
raising its fees earlier in the year, Sid Melksham. While the
ferry operators may at times be unable to raise the ramps, they
have no hesitation in raising the fares dramatically.
Although Melksham Inskip Point ferry operated free of charge during
"the barge wars" only a few years ago, he now
demands $50.00 per four wheel drive vehicle and an equal amount
for trailers. These vehicles spend less than an hour on Melksham's
ferries. Compare this with the $15 per four wheel drive vehicle
which has been going to the Government. (Trailers are free.)
These vehicles which may spend several days on Fraser Island.
The equity between the ferry fares and the use of Fraser Island
is incomparable.
Other tour operators have to pay Melksham $6 per head for each
passenger they carry but they only pay the Government $2.30 per
passenger per day. Thus every tourist visiting the island is
helping to swell his coffers. He now has a virtual monopoly on
traffic going to and from Fraser Island. Melksham is in a position
to exploit his monopoly and he is!
-o0o-
Paying the Dues
The Hervey Bay City Council has refused to upgrade
the Mary River Heads ferry landing. They found that despite the
fares being collected by operators, Mr Melksham had not met the
minimum council charges which had been raised two years ago from
$2.00 per day to $10.00. They calculate that Kingfisher Resort
owed them $6,990 and Eurong Resort $5,592. Melksham claimed that
he owned the barge landing but Council records show that they
purchased it from Dillinghams in 1975. In another move several
people advocated using $400,000 of unspent money which was to
have been used to construct a Moon Point landing to upgrade the
barge landing. At $10 per day, such an outlay would take a lot
of time to recover.
The Political Scene
The Queensland State Elections on 15 July created
a great surprise with its unexpected outcome. FIDO does not want
to become involved in pontificating about the reason for the cliff-hanger
result. It was the only recent Queensland election in which FIDO
played no part. This was not because as individuals we didn't
have any views but it was because as an organization FIDO had
no mission for supporting or censuring any particular political
party.
There was a split. Some conservation organizations favoured supporting
the Queensland Greens Party and censuring the Goss Government.
Most mainstream conservation bodies including the Australian
Conservation Foundation, The Wilderness Society and the Rainforest
Conservation Society saw enormous gains to be made if the Goss
Government were returned particularly for the Cape York Peninsula.
If all the conservation votes had gone to the Greens and preferences
allocated on parochial issues it is clear that there would be
a different political scene in Queensland now. Few are confident
that the environment would have benefitted.
Former Environment and Heritage Minister, Molly Robson lost her
seat of Springwood. Queensland now has a new Environment and
Heritage Minister, Tom Barton. FIDO remembers him as the TLC
Secretary who advocated that Labor honor its promise to make Fraser
Island World Heritage. However, after meeting him in October,
John Sinclair declared that he has the best grasp of the issues
relating to Fraser Island of any Queensland Environment Minister
he had met in 25 years.
There is little doubt that the National Party is changing. Shadow
Environment and Heritage Spokesperson, Doug Slack has moved a
long way from the earlier reactionary position of the Nationals
under Johannes Bjelke-Petersen. Opposition Leader Borbidge even
found himself pledging $10.5 million to improve Fraser Island
management during the Election Campaign. He accurately said that
the standard of infrastructure was declining under the Goss Government.
Apart from pledging $500,000 to upgrade the Mary River Heads
boat ramp, $10,000,000 would be spent on upgrading camping grounds
and picnic areas, road and track maintenance, new national park
walking tracks, tree planting and restoration, and resources surveys.
In Maryborough despite the 7% swing against the Goss Government
overall Bob Dollin's (ALP) margin dropped from only 3.3% to 0.8%
which he blamed largely on his position on the ballot paper.
In Hervey Bay, previously the most marginal seat in Queensland
the result went against the trend. Bill Nunn (ALP) was returned
with a margin of 856 votes out of more than 22,000.
The Goss Government had been initially very hesitant to pursue
conservation measures on Fraser Island. However, they are now
reaping a political dividend from their initiatives in having
it placed on the World Heritage and in ensuring that nobody in
the timber industry was disadvantaged in the process. However,
to capitalize on Fraser Island's World Heritage status, the Goss
Government now needs to make sure that it gets the management
it deserves. There is general bi-partisan agreement that the
DEH has not delivered the management appropriate to a World Heritage
site. The DEH however, has been reluctant to accept any other
participation in the process. FIDO hopes that Tom Barton will
be able to elevate his Department's performance in relation to
Fraser Island as well as in other areas.
It is worth reporting that when a former DEH employee resigned
after four years to take up a job with the voluntary conservation
movement a Director in the DEH regretted that she would now be
working for "the enemy". Unfortunately this
attitude is far too prevalent in the DEH.
Still Short of Senior Staff
The Great Sandy Region appears to be languishing.
There appears to be no sense of urgency for filling the many
of the senior positions vacant in the region.
The DEH continues to sit on its hands in failing to fill the position
of the Manager (Great Sandy). After more than a year the position
to oversee the implementation of the Management Plan has not even
been advertised. The DEH can't even decide what salary the position
should have. This is only one unfilled senior positions. The
long term staff shortages have resulted in serious neglect of
the region.
The fact that there is still no Board of Management and no immediate
plans to provide appropriate legislation to implement the Management
Plan is making the adoption of the Management Plan by the Goss
Government last year increasingly farcical.
New Fee Structure
Environment and Heritage Minister, Tom Barton, has
announced new access fees to Fraser Island as from January. This
will be the first rise for many years. Fees for passengers on
commercial tours will rise to $5.00 per day, (still less than
what Melksham charges on the barges). The price per vehicle will
rise to $25.00 which is half what the ferries charge. FIDO accepts
the charges have to rise but we have reservations.
a. The Queensland Government should not expect all
Fraser Island revenue has to be raised by visitor fees.
b. The DEH has to be drawn away from supporting events such as
the Fishing Expo on the basis of the revenue that such events
may generate.
c. FIDO and the public expect the Commonwealth Government to contribute
more to the cost of managing a World Heritage site on the basis
of both of their international obligations and the economic benefits
generated outside Fraser Island itself such as in Hervey Bay,
Maryborough, and even much further afield (e.g. airlines).
d. There has to be equity in what people pay for commercial tours
and for private visits.
Failure to Close Roads
In April, GO BUSH Safaris was advised
that it would have to revise itineraries for visiting Fraser Island
in October because some of the roads proposed to be traversed
and the beach south of the Sandy Cape Lighthouse were to be closed.
This information is contained in the DEH handouts first printed
in May. In August the Community Advisory Committee Meeting was
told that due to staff shortages DEH staff had not yet got around
to closing off the roads in question but they would do so as soon
as possible. By October not only had nothing been done. It takes
very little effort to close many of the tracks in question if
there is a will on the part of the DEH. The DEH has a "Road
Gang" of 8 men working full time on keeping tracks open but
they can't afford any human resources for closing any tracks.
It may only be coincidental that John Sinclair a principal advocate
for these track closures appears to be the person most affected
by the proposed closures. We now expect these tracks to be closed
before Christmas.
All the tracks should be closed and bollarded in the FIDO style
which would prevent the determined vandals who are determined
to push through to open up any track if at all possible.
Limit Vehicle Size: The size of many of the currently
used tour buses is excessive and inappropriate for Fraser Island.
Smaller vehicles will have less impact on the roads of Fraser
Island and enhance the quality of the experience of passengers
in a more intimate environment. While we support larger buses
being phased out, we also believe that urgent action needs to
be taken to limit the size of other heavy vehicles using the cross
island tracks. These are having a devastating impact on one of
Fraser Island's great icons, Wanggoolba Creek as well as the roads.
The impact of the vibrations and sediment washing off the track
beside this beautiful stream is quite serious and must be addressed
as a matter of urgency.
The road from Central Station to Pile Valley should be closed
to all vehicles over 3 tonnes gross. This will mean that large
buses must avoid this section of track and that all heavy transport
vehicles (including the Department of Environment and Heritage
garbage compactor) would have to find alternative routes, either
by the old DM Minerals haul road or the beach.
Vale Les Greensill
FIDO recently lost a very good friend. For almost
20 years Les Greensill provided the transport for FIDO Safaris
to Fraser Island. When he ceased operations it effectively put
an end to viable FIDO Safaris.
As FIDO Treasurer Terry Hampson said so eloquently:
Les was a good friend of our organization and the members of
our Executive during the bad times as well as the good. We will
all remember the happy times spent with him on Fraser Island,
his quick wit, his tolerance and his great driving. Our organization
is deeply saddened by his passing.
FIDO extends our deepest condolences to the Greensill family.
Sandy Cape Light Saga
Correction: De-Staffed? Not yet:
MOONBI 87 reported that the Sandy Cape Light was to be automated
and de-staffed as from July. This information was incorrect.
Although termination notices were issued to the two light keepers,
Dudley Fulton and Aubrey Strydom in May, these notices were withdrawn
within days. Both light keepers are still there pending the satisfactory
hand-over of the light station buildings (except for the light
tower itself) from the Commonwealth Government's AMSA (Australian
Marine Safety Authority) to the QDEH. The two light-keepers future
is indeterminate. They will probably remain until at least the
end of 1995.
Automated: On 5 July, the Sandy Cape light station was
now automated but the current light is now the dimmest in the
125 year history of the Sandy Cape light. The solar powered batteries
operate a 12 volt 100 watt light which with magnification should
have a range of 21 nautical miles. AMSA wants to augment it with
two auxiliary lights and the Queensland maritime authorities are
also considering a further light for the Queensland territorial
waters of Hervey Bay. The light it replaced a 120-volt 1000-watt
quartz-iodide, tungsten-halogen light, magnified by prisms to
an intensity of half a million candles and visible for 44 kilometres
to sea.
Other Navigational Aids: FIDO understands that AMSA has
abandoned the idea of a light tower at the end of Breaksea Spit
on economic grounds but AMSA still wants an on-shore light though
at Middle Rocks to indicate a shoal south east of Indian Head.
FIDO awaits resolution of negotiations between the DEH and AMSA
about this light which will have an environmental impact and
what the State is planning for a Rooney's Point light.
FIDO is also very anxious that the other light station in the
Great Sandy Region, Double Island Point, which had been
proposed as a potential resort site should be incorporated into
the Great Sandy National Park (Cooloola). Any developments on
this site would have adverse consequences on the environment.
Sandy Cape Turtle Tagging
Although we had been under the impression that few
turtles nested on Fraser Island compared with the islands of the
Great Barrier Reef, the Sandy Cape light keepers tagged 40 green
turtles which nested on the beach between Sandy Cape and Rooneys
Point last summer. Only two loggerheads were recorded. This
makes Fraser Island more significant as a turtle rookery than
previously thought. With the loss of staff at Sandy Cape the
tagging program there could lapse. Much of this beach is due
to become vehicle free. This may happen before the turtle nesting
season is far advanced.
Bird Count (or Birds Don't Count)
Shorebirds:
On 8 October one dead oyster catcher on the beach between Eurong
and Dilli Village represented over 10% of the total number of
oyster catchers which can now be observed between Hook Point and
Indian Head. While the number is variable depending on the time
and tide when the count is made the number of oyster catchers
continues to plunge to an alarming level.
We are now of the view that while vehicles are killing
some birds there is an associated problem resulting from free
range camping which is disturbing the nesting and breeding patterns
of the oyster-catchers and dotterals in the foredunes. Campers,
by their presence are innocently, and unaware of their impact,
preventing the successful breeding of Fraser Island's two principal
resident waders.
FIDO had thought the number of Red capped dotterals along the
Ocean Beach hadn't diminished significantly but recent counting
suggests that their numbers are also dropping along the Ocean
Beach which is most heavily used by traffic. In three separate
counts we averaged only about 8 dotterals between Dilli Village
and Wabby Lakes.
Seabirds: On 17 October many dead sea birds, including
more than 6 Australasian gannets were washed ashore on Fraser
Island's Ocean Beach after a severe storm. Several weak and injured
birds were similarly washed ashore and rescued. One huge Shy
albatross was handed into the DEH for caring. Such occurrences
of seabirds being caught in storms and dying is not unusual.
It was unusual though that these birds should be in Fraser Island
waters in mid October.
Weeds
We have long been concerned at the escape of weeds
from various settlements and the DEH has begun addressing our
concerns. Most of the weeds which escaped from the gardens at
Dilli Village have been eliminated from Dilli Village but those
which have spread outside Dilli Village including many succulents
are still evident from the track leading to Lake Boomanjin. The
work of weed eradication needs to be extended.
The DEH staff has begun a massive task of eliminating the sisal
plants from the Bogimbah area. The weeds originally were introduced
to the Aboriginal "missions" to teach the people how
to weave in the same way as the Maori people had learnt to weave.
The Aborigines were judged to be culturally inferior to the Maoris
because they didn't weave. Now the weeds are spreading rapidly
and smothering the Bogimbah area where in less than 8 years from
1897 to 1905 about 100 people died and are buried. This was out
of a settlement population of never more than 350 Aborigines.
BBBs Active on Fraser Island
(BBB = Bush bashing blighters) The presence of bush
bashing four wheel drivers and other "cowboy" types
on Fraser Island is becoming increasingly evident as is their
militancy. There is no doubt that there are some people on Fraser
Island determined that there should be no road closures and no
restrictions.
Reopening old tracks: A "Road Closed" sign on
an old track to Lake Bowarrady (which was been closed for years)
was deliberately pushed down about 11 October. A BBB in a four
wheel drive had driven up with a bull bar and pushed the sign
down smashing its base. When reported to the DEH staff they advised
that during the 1994 fire when all staff were engaged in fire
fighting about 60 signs were removed in one section of Fraser
Island alone.
It appears that the disciples of the Public Land Users are alive
and well in Queensland and particularly on Fraser Island. Their
actions must be curbed.
Closing the sandblows: It had been thought that with the
Management Plan approved DEH staff would take steps to ensure
that vehicles were confined to tracks. The fact is that fresh
wheel tracks were observed in Bingih Sandblow (just north of Orchid
Beach) on 5 October. They had traversed the whole sandblow.
Some action is overdue to confine vehicles to tracks and the beaches
below the high tide mark.
Fuel for the Critics: Wood gathering on Fraser Island
has reached a new low. Several standing tree skeletons in Bingih
Sandblow north of Waddy Point have been chopped up presumably
for firewood. This wood is thousands of years old having been
entombed by the sandblow for much of that time and then as it
was exhumed by the advancing sandblow it has been etched and sculptured
by the blasts of sand laden winds into some amazing shapes. The
sacrilege that thoughtless visitors should casually remove such
important artifacts from the sandblows with such indifference
indicates that there needs to be a lot of better public education
on Fraser Island yet.
Courtesy: In the past one of the attributes of being in
a remote area was the willingness of any one to help a fellow
traveller in difficulty. This camaraderie is rapidly dying on
Fraser Island. The "ME" society is becoming far more
evident amongst many of Fraser Island's visitors. When thanked
for backing up to let two larger vehicles past recently the driver
only snarled back, "Next time you can back up!"
This is only one example of unpleasant behavior. It should not
have rated much mention except that unfortunately it is becoming
more commonplace.
Orchid Beach Airstrip Closure: Although the Orchid Beach
airstrip was supposed to be closed several months ago, on Monday,
2 October, members of a GO BUSH Safaris witnessed
a light aircraft landing on the airstrip in the twilight. There
has been no attempt to dig up the airstrip or to block it off
to prevent fixed wing aircraft continuing to use it and they appear
to be doing this informally with the knowledge of DEH staff.
Walking Trails
The Army has recently helped with some overdue work
on Fraser Island walking tracks. The southern approach to Wabby
Lakes has been dramatically improved with new steps. While the
Army is believed to have done more track work this was the only
work observed. It would be handy if a standard for walking tracks
was developed because there were some places along the walking
trail especially where there are side-cuttings on the hills where
some kerbing would be if some assistance to reduce further erosion.
Eli Creek Boardwalk: The Eli Creek boardwalk is sinking.
A large part of the upstream bridge is now under water. In places
it is unsafe. Nothing has been done since this was drawn to the
attention of the Community Advisory Committee in August. Hundreds
of visitors to Eli Creek each day (including passengers carried
by commercial tour operators) have to walk through water because
much of the boardwalk is sinking. However, despite this disaster,
tour operators are more concerned about widening roads to ensure
the paint work of their coaches are not scratched than they are
by the state of the boardwalk. For three months after it was
first reported to the Acting manager (Great Sandy) nothing was
done.
FIDO has a particular interest because the Queensland Government
destroyed the original boardwalk constructed by FIDO with voluntary
labour and had the present Eli Creek project constructed at a
cost to the taxpayers of $345,000 in about 1986-87. More working
bees may be required to fix up the Eli Creek board-walk because
the main beneficiaries of the work, namely the tour operators
both oppose any rise in fees paid to the DEH and want the $2.30
per person per day spent on roads to make it easier for their
buses than on walking tracks for their passengers.
Wanggoolba Creek: Boards have been falling off part of
the Wanggoolba Creek walk for months. Elsewhere the track which
is walked by an average of one hundred people on most days, is
showing severe signs of wear. No work has been carried out by
the DEH to rectify the accelerating degradation along this walk.
It needs to have some kerbing such as logs laid along the lower
side of the track for most of its length to arrest the movement
of sand into the stream and to prevent further erosion of exposed
tree roots. Unless this and road work to the track above the
walking trail is undertaken urgently one of Fraser Island's most
attractive icons will be seriously degraded (possibly) beyond
repair within our lifetime.
Signs Of Older Times
It is time that there were some more new interpretive
signs on Fraser Island. It is now four years since logging ceased
on Fraser Island but the old signs erected by the Queensland Forestry
Service extolling the way timber operations "are being
conducted on Fraser Island" are still present at Central
Station and are being seen by hundreds of people daily. The worst
example is on an old Peebang (Syncarpia hillii) beside
the Wanggoolba Creek boardwalk. This is overdue for updating.
Some interpretations needed at Eli Creek. FIDO's sign on interpretation
there was destroyed along with all other evidence that FIDO had
ever had anything to do with this project. There are many other
areas where interpretive signs would be helpful.
Cultural Icons Going: Some more interpretation signs and
curatorial work is also needed particularly for items of cultural
significance. Many of the gunyah trees and trees where Aborigines
once robbed bees nests are dying. The few that are left deserve
to be recognized before they too go. The southern walking track
to Wabby Lakes passed right beside one "Gunyah tree".
However, this went unrecognized and unsigned and when a fig
growing up the centre of this dead tree split, nothing was done
to preserve it and the broken part was ripped away and thrown
down beside the track. It would help more people to appreciate
the cultural significance of Fraser Island if a more concerted
effort were made to explain the significance of particular sites.
For example the gunyah tree beside the track to Lake Allom and
the canoe trees near Happy Valley should have interpretive signs
beside them and some curatorial work to help protect these living
links with the traditional Aboriginal culture.
Advertising Hoardings Proliferate
MOONBI 87 reported our concern at the ugly proliferation
of commercial signs in the public lands on Fraser Island. Huge
unauthorized signs now appear on public land at Cathedral Beach,
Happy Valley and Eurong. (The latter is quite new). Now the
proliferation extends to real estate signs on a trailer art Eurong
being park conspicuously on the beach at Eurong.
We warned of the precedents being established but we were unaware
of one sign which appears in the National Park at Orchid Beach.
Toyota still enjoys free advertising at Orchid Beach more than
6 months after the Fishing Expo and FIDO who has a Freedom of
Information request in relating to arrangements for the Fishing
Expo are keen to see whether there is any reference to this in
the DEH reports.
Fortunately the DEH has replaced signs at Orchid Beach with official
signs indicating that there is a shop and fuel supplies. The
commercial signs for the Kingfisher Resort were removed. Why
is the DEH turning a blind eye to the more monstrous signs which
are now appearing and which have no place on Fraser Island. Even
the commercial joy flights now have advertising billboards parked
on the beach near their take off points.
The proliferation of inappropriate signs needs to be addressed.
Unfortunately the Development Control Plan (DCP) which is supposed
to be developed is being kept so much under the wraps that we
don't know whether this is going to address the matter of advertising
hoardings.
What's In a Name?
Notices at Waddy Point advise visitors not to bury
fish offal between Waddy Point itself and "Connors Corner".
Regular visitor to Fraser Island for the past 25 years have not
previously heard of "Connors Corner". However, we presume
that it refers to the professional fishers who have maintained
a permanent camp on beach near the main Waddy Point camping ground
since the early 1980s.
(It is an interesting irony that when police were
used to shift "greenie" protesters in 1990 when they
had camped on one site more than 6 weeks nothing has been done
to shift these permanent squatters). Many of the fishers seem
to have close relationship with ranger staff. Some camps have
the whole ground covered in carpet and steel beams supporting
huge canopies.
In 1978-79 the Queensland Place Names Board established a subcommittee
to review all place names on Fraser Island in response to past
practice of applying unapproved names. Now the practice of using
unauthorized names which the Board thought had been addressed
has been resumed by the DEH.
Local Authority Boundaries
FIDO has patiently waited now for more than four
years for the review of the Local Government boundaries in the
Great Sandy Region to give effect to Commissioner Fitzgerald's
Recommendation 29 in the Commission of Inquiry into the Conservation,
Management and Use of Fraser Island and the Great Sandy Region
to reduce the number of local authorities with direct management
responsibilities for parts of the Great Sandy Region.
Fitzgerald recommended: Consideration be given to in a review
of local authority boundaries by the Electoral and Administrative
Review Commission (EARC) to the alteration of the boundaries of
the cities of Maryborough and Hervey Bay and the shires of Noosa
and Widgee and the inclusion of the whole region within one local
authority area or the inclusion of the whole of Fraser Island
in one local authority area and he inclusion of the entire mainland
part of the region into one other local authority area.
In 1992, the Parliamentary Committee of EARC recommended : "12.43:
The Committee considers that Fraser Island should be placed under
the jurisdiction of one local authority. ... and 12.43 The Committee
considers that Fraser Island as a unique environment requiring
very careful protection. In particular the Committee endorses
recommendation 29 of the report of the Commission of Inquiry into
the Conservation, Management and Use of Fraser Island and the
Great Sandy Region be referred to on-going boundaries review mechanism
..."
On 29 March, 1993, the Local Government Minister wrote to the
Local Government Commissioner, Mr G.T. Hoffman, urging him to
act on the EARC reviews with respect to Fraser Island and the
Great Sandy Region.
Although Commissioner Hoffman has still to undertake this Review
of the Maryborough- Hervey Bay- Noosa- Cooloola External boundaries
his latest correspondence indicates that the matter is still
on the agenda. We are beginning to become impatient.
Fraser Island Visitor Statistics
| 1993-94 | 1994-95 |
| Permits | People | Permits | People |
(1 month) permits | 33,202 | 120,323 | 33,713 | 122,797 |
(12 month) permits | 403 | n.a. | 370 | n.a. |
Permits to camp | 20,087 | 82,765 | 20,054 | 84,031 |
Exemption labels | 469 | ó | 527 | n.a |
Commercial Tours | 136,860 | 141,434 |
| 257,184 | 264,231 |
Source: 1995 DEH Annual Report
The number of private visitors increased by 2% and the number
of tour operator passengers increased by 1.5% on the operators
self regulated returns. The slight fall off in camper numbers
first observed three years ago continued. The number of requests
for first aid and emergency services also fell slightly from 1111
to 1029, the number of evacuations fell from 87 to 63 but the
number of deaths jumped from 2 to 4 with the accidental death
of two men on Indian Head. In each year there were two deaths
from natural causes.
Digest from the Diary
These are a few of the items we noted which were
reported in the regional media relating to Fraser Island not commented
on elsewhere in this issue:
March: FIDO Denied Funds: Although FIDO applied for a
grant offered by the DEH to Non-Government Conservation Organizations,
we never received any advice of what had happened to our application.
The truth is that the DEH didn't reply, acknowledge or advise,
but the former Environment and Heritage Minister's office decided
that under no circumstances would FIDO get any grant for 1995-96
(not even the smallest grant made to any group ($1000) which
FIDO had received in 1994-95. It appears that the DEH wants a
compliant, uncritical conservation movement in Queensland. This
has also been demonstrated by conservation groups being referred
to as "the enemy" within DEH.
The denial of any government funds will handicap FIDO's efforts
but they won't stop us from continuing to advocate better management
of Fraser Island.
March: Fraser Funds Disappear Up North: The Federal Member
for Wide Bay, Warren Truss, has made a series of well researched
allegations of how $3 million of the allocated $50 million taxpayers
funds "were given away to North Queensland because the
Goss Government had not found A way of spending it. ... Proposals
to upgrade communication facilities and to investigate a proposed
light rail system were refused on the grounds that no money was
available."
May 2: 14th CAC Meeting in Gympie. The DEH fails
inform on participants on critical issues. The news blackout
included the Fishing Expo and allowing 200 ha destined to be included
in the Cooloola National Park to be given to Telstra for a communications
facility.
May 17: Kingfisher Resort was complaining that
there was a convention facility within 100 miles of Hervey Bay
which could cater for more than 100 people. They claim to be
able to accommodate 300 delegates and 600 house guests.
22 May: Fishing Expo Issue re-ignites
May - June: Molly Robson gave the nod to spray mosquito
breeding areas of Great Sandy Region including the very controversial
Mary River Heads which is the habitat of the rare and endangered
Illidges Blue Butterfly.
9 July: SS Maheno" marks 60 years on the beach on
Fraser Island. The last decade has seen accelerated decay of
this once "Greyhound of the Tasman".
17 July: Thoorgine Camp Ground Opened: Queensland Governor,
Leneen Forde, opened the Thoorgine Centre's eco-camping ground.
FIDO in 1984 passed on a $2,000 bequest from foundation Vice-President,
Mary Hansen to Thoorgine to facilitate the development of a camping
ground. The establishment of the Recreation Area over Fraser
Island ended FIDO's plans to develop a camping ground near Chard's
Rocks. At the same time the establishment of Thoorgine by the
Butchalla people provided us with an opportunity to apply Mary's
bequest to the purpose for which it was intended. The new camping
ground is a very good development although FIDO remains anxious
about many exotic plants which were introduced to the site which
have the propensity to run feral and introduce new injurious agencies
to Fraser Island. FIDO is keen to see the main feature of Thoorgine,
the Cultural Centre, developed as soon as possible.
26-30 July: An International Whale
Conference at Hervey Bay attracted representatives from
Japan, Argentina, Scotland, New Zealand. Organized by ANCA this
focussed on whale watching and indicates that it is now big business
and Hervey Bay is one of the world's major whale watching venues.
29 July: Hervey Bay continues to be one of Australia's
fastest growing cities. It has grown by 43.5% or 11,300 during
the last five years to now have a population of 37,300. With
a projected growth of 46.8% projected growth over the next ten
years (17,500) it will reach 54,800 by 2005.
8 August: 15th CAC Meeting in Gympie. Dissatisfaction
and frustration with the lack of progress in implementation of
the Management Plan is so widespread that all participants agree
to form a bi-partisan delegation to the Minister to express the
group's feelings. The Minister has not yet agreed to a meeting.
23 August: Mary River Heads Barge Landing will not be
funded by the Hervey Bay City Council. (See story on $12,000
barge landing fees owing to the council in this MOONBI)
19 October: Terry Hampson and John Sinclair meet new
Environment and Heritage Minister, Tom Barton. He is given
the thumbs up as the best Queensland Environment Minister yet.
28 October: Two former executives of the Pivot group,
which once owned the sandmining leases on Fraser Island and Shoalwater
Bay were fined for their were fined for misuse of company funds
in share transactions in 1989-90. Their former boss, and main
beneficiary of the deal, Peter Laurance, was found not
guilty by a jury. FIDO dubbed Laurance "Mr. Mickey Mouse"
when he became the head of the Queensland Tourist and travel Corporation
for advocating building more Disney type theme parks in Queensland.
No doubt the comic outcome of the recent litigation will have
him smiling.
31 October: The DEH unilaterally cancelled the
Community Advisory Committee meeting scheduled for 6 November
although the meeting had been programmed since February and a
Notice of Meeting had been issued less than two weeks earlier.
It appears the main reason for cancelling the meeting was that
the DEH was unprepared. They had not arranged the speakers on
the scheduled topic of fisheries to come to the meeting.
30 October: Inskip Point Land Buy Back: The Queensland
Government announced that it had bought out the Big Australian's"
real estate at Inskip Point which is a major advance towards limiting
the population of Rainbow Beach, and the impacts on Cooloola National
Park and Fraser Island. The development leases had been granted
in 1984 in exchange for sandmining leases along the Queensland
coast. The potentially disastrous proposal to build a resort
for 3,000 people and a marina "would have placed intolerable
strains on the World Heritage area" according to Premier
Goss. FIDO applauds this action.
1 November: Parliamentary Inquiry Cans Inadequate Fraser
Funding: John Sinclair presents FIDO's submissions on Fraser
Island being a Cinderella to the House of Representatives Standing
Committee on the Environment, Recreation and the Arts in Sydney.
This theme was acknowledged by the Chair at the Brisbane hearings
on 15 November where FIDO's views were echoed by several other
groups including residents, Kingfisher Resort, Thoorgine Educational
and Cultural Centre and more. Residents spokesman called Fraser
Island a Third World Heritage area. John Langmore MP said Fraser
Island was one of the worst examples of extraordinarily badly
funded World Heritage areas. He said the Commonwealth had
to take the ultimate responsibility to ensure that World Heritage
areas were managed to a world standard.
6-7 November: In lieu of attending the DEH John Sinclair
pursues FoI searches and meets with senior DEH officers in Brisbane.
The Maryborough office hadn't advised them that the CAC meeting
was to be cancelled.
November: The Brisbane City Council launched its own FIDO
campaign. They weren't barking up the wrong tree. They identified
a successful campaign and decided that they could have as much
success in "Finding Irresponsible Dog Owners!" This
organization doesn't have a patent on our name. We wish the BCC
well in their campaign to educate dog owners to control their
pets. Other organizations have been known as FIDO but the Watchdog
of Fraser Island is clearly the best known FIDO in Australia.
November: Minister announces that Fraser Island Fees will
rise as from January
Fraser Island Defenders Organization
Ltd
President's Annual Report
August 1995
The last 12 months have seen a few high Points but
a lot of frustration for FIDO.
Despite World Heritage listing of Fraser Island, we are still
waiting for the majority of the island to become National Park.
The Government assures us that the only delay is the resolution
of the claims on parts of the island under the Native Titles Act.
FIDO has always been keen for the former owners of Fraser Island
to have their claims to the island recognized, but are of the
opinion that the declaration of the National Park in no way lessens
the validity of their claim. We hope the declaration occurs within
the next 12 months.
The State Government's Management Plan for the Great Sandy Region
is in place, but there is still no agreement between the State
and Federal Governments over the structure of the Committee to
oversee its implementation. FIDO met on several occasions with
the former Environment Minister, Molly Robson, to express our
concerns over her proposed committee structure . We will meet
with her successor, Tom Barton, in the near future in an attempt
to get this resolved.
The announcement during the election campaign by the State Government
that it intends to renominate the Cooloola National Park part
of the Great Sandy Region for World Heritage Listing is welcomed.
FIDO will be liaising with local groups to ensure that the best
nomination is put forward, and we hope that the entire Great Sandy
Region will be on the World Heritage List by the end of 1997.
This has important management implications for Fraser Island
and the mainland part of the GSR. Tourism to Fraser Island has
boomed since World Heritage Listing, especially amongst backpackers.
The Cooloola area can expect a similar increase in visitation
once listed, which may take some pressure off Fraser but pose
new problems for Cooloola. The State election saw the National
Party announce that, despite claims from their Hervey Bay candidate
that World Heritage Listing was a barrier to tourism, the Nationals
would not revoke WHL. It took 23 years for them to start supporting
our arguments. We await their support on visitor numbers, beach
closures , etc.
The FIDO Executive made several trips to Fraser Island over the
last 12 months to get a better idea of what is happening on the
ground. Each time we have found several alarming things which
we have subsequently taken up with the Minister and her advisers.
We have been fortunate to meet Keith Twyford on a couple of occasions
on the island, and been able to raise our concerns directly with
him as well.
Over the next 12 months we will be meeting with the new Environment
and Heritage Minister, Tom Barton, and will also have a new Director
General of the Department to deal with. Trips to the island will
be an important part of our research, and with the nomination
of Cooloola pending we may also be able to include this on our
travels.
Thanks to the Executive who have worked well together over the
last 12 months, especially Billie, Terry and Judy who get to do
most of the work. Also to Keith Sinclair for his work on the
membership list. Thanks also to Ted, John Davey, Brian, Margaret
and Nicky.
John Sinclair Snr deserves special thanks. Somehow he manages
to juggle FIDO, GO BUSH Safaris , his family and
other interests. He does most of the media work, produces MOONBI,
and gets to the island more often than most of us for inspections
and monitoring.
The next 12 months will doubtless be busy for FIDO, and we appreciate
the continued support of our members.
Ian Matthews
President, August 1995
Join FIDO's Next Inspection
The FIDO Executive plans to spend the weekend of
3-4 February, 1996 carrying out a critical inspection on Fraser
Island to help us review and develop policy and to keep in touch
with the island. We plan to be accommodated at Dilli Village
and form car pools to travel on the island in a minimum number
of four wheel drive vehicles. In the past we have been accompanied
by a DEH officer and in February we hope that this level of informal
contact with DEH staff can be extended.
The FIDO Executive has also invited members of the Noosa Parks
Association to join this so that the watchdogs of Cooloola (Fraser
Island's sister sandmass) can appreciate Fraser Island and the
issues associated with its management. Similarly FIDO members
are invited to join NPA members the following day, Monday, 5 February
to review the issues relating to Cooloola.
We plan to leave Brisbane on Friday lunch time and return about
7.00 pm on Sunday night. FIDO members / supporters interested
in joining one or both of these inspections should advise Terry
Hampson (Telephone (07) 3403 7250 (w) or 3261 1601 (H) to notify
your intentions if you wish to join this inspection. Please advise
if you can provide four wheel drive transport or whether you require
transport and whether you would like to rendezvous with the group
at Brisbane (12.00 noon on Friday) or Rainbow Beach (3.15 pm Friday).
We need to know who is interested in going by Wednesday 24 January
so that we can coordinate transport and get back to everyone and
discuss the arrangements. The costs will be shared but they should
amount to less than $120 per person for the weekend including
food, transport and accommodation.
The Fraser Island inspection, lead by John Sinclair, is timed
to assess the impact of the summer holiday traffic and immediately
precede a Community Advisory Committee Meeting in Gympie on 6
February. The 1996 inspection aims at looking particularly at
the developments in the Orchid Beach - Waddy Point area.
|